Audit your app
Website Audit Service: How to Choose One Before You Pay
A buyer's guide to website audit services: the 3 kinds, the questions to ask before you pay, and the red flags worth walking away from.
The right website audit service is the one that answers your question. SEO audits look at whether people can find you in search, accessibility audits look at who can use your site, and visitor-eye audits look at whether a new person understands and trusts it. Figure out which kind you need first, then ask a short list of questions before you pay anybody anything.
If you made a site or app, maybe with an AI tool, and you're wondering whether a customer would actually get it, this guide will help you choose, compare, and avoid paying for the wrong thing. Full disclosure: we sell one of these. I'll tell you exactly how ours works as we go, so you can hold it to the same questions.
What are the 3 kinds of website audit service?
The same name gets slapped on 3 very different products.
- An SEO audit. SEO stands for search engine optimization. Google's starter guide describes it as helping search engines understand your content and helping people decide whether to visit. It also says, very plainly, that nothing in it will automatically rank you first. I appreciate the honesty.
- An accessibility audit. This checks whether people with disabilities can use your site. The W3C, the group that sets web standards, says no tool alone can determine whether a site meets accessibility standards, and that knowledgeable human evaluation is required. Its WCAG-EM method is an approach for judging conformance with the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines, so it's fair to ask any accessibility auditor which method they follow.
- A visitor-eye audit. This reads your site the way a new visitor would. Is it clear what this is? Does it look trustworthy? Can someone get through the main path? A speed or SEO scan answers a different question, whether the page is quick and findable, and it won't tell you whether your headline explains what you sell. Ours is this kind.
Which kind should you buy first?
Start from the decision sitting in front of you.
- Nobody is finding the site: an SEO audit (our website SEO audit checklist lets you run the basics yourself first).
- Someone has asked you for an accessibility review, or you serve people who rely on assistive tools: an accessibility specialist.
- People arrive and leave, or you're about to put the site in front of customers, investors, or press: a visitor-eye audit.
They aren't rivals, and plenty of sites eventually need more than one. The questions below work for all 3 kinds.
What should you ask before you pay?
6 questions, in the order I'd ask them.
- Which kind of audit is this, and what question does it answer? If the sales page can't say, expect a little of everything and not much of anything.
- What exactly will it look at? You want the address, the pages, the screen sizes, and the date written down, so you know what the findings are based on.
- Who or what does the reviewing? A person, software, or both, and which part is which. Ours is an AI audit scored against a fixed rubric (a set of questions asked the same way of every site). No person reads your app, which is why it comes back in minutes.
- Can you read a sample report first? If there isn't one, you're buying blind. Ours is public, and it shows the audit run on our own site.
- What does it need from you, and what will it touch? Google's advice on hiring an SEO is to grant only read access to Search Console during an audit. We need a link to your public site and your email address. No account.
- What will the report say it couldn't check? Ours isn't a security review or a full accessibility audit, and where something couldn't be tested, the report says so.
How do price and refund terms differ?
Prices come in 3 shapes: a one-time fee, a subscription that re-checks your site over time, or a custom quote. None of them is wrong. A one-time fee suits a first read before you launch, a subscription suits a site that changes every week, and a quote suits a bigger site with special needs.
Whatever the shape, ask 3 things. What's the total cost, including any renewal? How soon do you get the result, and do you get to keep it? And what are the refund terms, in writing, including what happens if the review can't finish?
For reference, ours is $27, one time, with no account and nothing that renews. Results come back in minutes, and the report is yours to keep. If you don't find it useful, you can request a full refund within 24 hours of your report being delivered by opening your report and answering 3 short questions. If an audit can't finish, it's refunded automatically.
What does a visitor-eye audit score?
A fixed set of questions, asked the same way every time, so findings from different weeks or different sites sit on the same footing. Ours covers six product dimensions, from Clarity and Promise (would a new visitor know what this is?) to Conversion and The Ask (is the next step specific?). Whatever you're weighing, use its list of areas as a yardstick. Can you tell what each area is asking? Would the same question get asked of any site?
What should the report hand you?
A score you can repeat to a teammate, a verdict in plain words, and a ranked list of fixes. Ours has a score out of 100, a Verdict label, a "Where to start" panel, and per-area fields for what works, slop tells, and top fixes. For the full picture, read our guide on what a good audit report includes. As a buyer, you really only need to check one thing. Can you tell what to do first?
What does a useful finding look like?
Take a bookkeeping app for small cafes (made up). A weak finding says, "The homepage could be clearer." That leaves you nowhere to start. A useful finding has 4 parts:
- What a visitor sees: the headline reads "Work smarter," and nothing on the first screen says this is bookkeeping for cafe owners.
- Why it matters: a cafe owner has to guess whether this is for them before they scroll.
- The fix: replace the headline with one sentence naming who it's for and what it does.
- How to check it: show someone who's never seen the app only the new headline, and ask what it does.
The test is simple. Could you do something on Monday morning because of that finding? If not, it's filler.
Which red flags should make you walk away?
Some sales pages tell you everything you need to know. Walk away if you see:
- A promise about rankings, traffic, or sales. Google's hiring guidance says no one can guarantee a number 1 ranking, and that an audit should give realistic estimates of improvement and of the work involved.
- A claim that an automated scan "certifies" your accessibility. The W3C says no tool alone can determine that.
- A method the seller won't explain. Google also warns about secretive providers.
- A score with no reasons, or findings that fit any site, like "improve your user experience."
- No date, no scope, and no mention of what wasn't checked.
- A request for more access than the job needs.
How do you compare 2 audits fairly?
Give both the same page on the same day. Read the top finding from each and run the Monday-morning test. Don't compare scores across services, though. Different questions produce numbers that mean different things. Scores are most useful when the same review runs on the same pages before and after you make changes.
A website audit service earns its fee when it hands you a short, ranked, honest list you can act on this week.
Sources, all read 5 October 2026: Google's SEO starter guide (updated 10 December 2025), the W3C's guidance on evaluating accessibility (updated 12 August 2026), and Google's guidance on hiring an SEO (updated 5 June 2026).
